Southeastern Wild Turkey populations have benefited from the combination of translocation and strict harvest guidelines. In certain cases, translocation of wildlife species can have long-lasting consequences. This is particularly true if translocations occur from hybrid zones (where two subspecies interbreed) to reintroduction sites. Here, Dave Godwin holds a beautiful bird killed in Clay County, Mississippi. Photo courtesy of Dave Godwin, Mississippi Department of Wildlife, Fisheries and Parks.
Wildlife Science

Wild Turkey Subspecies and Hybridization: The Value of Genetic Analysis in Wildlife Management

BF
Ph.D. candidate
Brant Faircloth is a Ph.D. candidate at the University of Georgia (UGA) studying genetics in wildlife ecosystems with an emphasis on upland game bird ecology. To learn more about their research and other current gamebird-related research projects at the University of Georgia, visit the UGA Gamebird Lab website: http://gamebird.forestry.uga.edu/research/.
TT
Ph.D.
Dr. Theron Terhune is a Wildlife Biologist and Research Scientist at a privately-owned property near Wilmington, NC and a Research Fellow at the Spatial Informatics Group – Natural Assets Laboratory (SIG-NAL). He received a B.S. and M.S. degree from Auburn University in Wildlife Science and a Ph.D. in Forestry and Natural Resources at the University of Georgia. Theron has studied gamebirds and fire-affiliated species for more than 20 years during which he has published 65 scientific articles in peer-reviewed journals and 34 popular magazine articles.

Issue: May/June 2007 · Season: Year-Round

a long lasting (10 year) reduction in density for the particular area inhabited by that social group. In other words, in areas plagued by deer overabundance, managers may want to focus on an intensive, local removal of deer rather than a broad-scale, less intensive effort.

In order to evaluate the applicability of the theory to the Southeast, Chris and his collaborators radio-tagged and collected samples for genetic analysis from deer on a large study site in South Carolina. They used a class of genetic markers identical to those used in Randy DeYoung’s study. In addition to allowing the determination of the mother(s) and father(s) of particular offspring, these markers can also be used to determine other familial relationships (e.g. siblings, first-cousins, second-cousins).

After collecting and analyzing both their radio-tag and genetic data, these researchers came to the conclusion that the rose-petal hypothesis, as it is currently stated, did not appear to apply to deer on their study site. In other words, they found that while older does did appear to stay within the same general area, additional does in close proximity did not appear to be close relatives. Therefore, the rose-petal model may not apply to the population studied, and management actions based on the rose-petal model may not be applicable on similar areas throughout the Southeast.

In contrast to the multiple paternity study, in which new behaviors were identified, this genetic research sought to investigate an existing management-related theory. The results, while surprising, indicate that a localized management strategy, based on the rose-petal mode, may be much less useful than initially thought. Furthermore, it implies that management actions based on the model may not be warranted in typical southeastern habitats. Along with the prior examples, the flexibility and contribution of genetic analysis to wildlife management should start to become evident.

Wild Turkey Subspecies and Hybridization

Genetic studies are certainly not limited to mammals. Along with her collaborators, Emily Latch at Purdue University used genetic markers to investigate patterns of Wild Turkey subspecies and hybridization. Put another way, Emily looked at the existence and location of wild turkey subspecies throughout the state of Kansas.

This study determined that Eastern wild turkeys tend to inhabit Eastern Kansas with Rio Grande turkeys found in central and western Kansas. Interestingly, this research identified 2 areas in which the results were different from their expectations: an area in east-central Kansas where turkeys appeared to be Eastern+Rio Grande hybrids and another area at the southwestern corner of the state where the turkeys appeared to be Merriam’s+Rio Grande hybrids.

From a management standpoint, this becomes very important if you begin to think about translocation of turkeys for reintroduction to certain areas. As most of you know, the now phenomenal turkey populations we enjoy throughout the Southeast are a result of careful management by state game agencies and the re-introduction of turkeys to many areas from which they had disappeared (Figure 3).

Results from this study underscore the importance of knowing the location and genetic makeup of the source population used for translocation. If we want to reintroduce pure, Eastern turkeys to an area, we need to ensure the individuals we are relocating are actually a pure subspecies rather than a hybrid strain (which may be very similar in appearance). This is not only true for turkeys – it extends to other species we may translocate and reintroduce in the future.

A somewhat extreme example should clarify why this is important. Consider for a moment that we want to translocate turkeys to an area where they are present in very low numbers. Prior to taking this management action, we must identify a source population from which to collect the individuals being translocated. We should also ensure these individuals are: (1) genetically similar to turkeys in the area of reintroduction and (2) genetically “healthy” (have high levels of genetic diversity). Genetically similar individuals may be better adapted for survival and reproduction in local habitats than genetically dissimilar individuals. Genetically diverse individuals should be more resistant to disease or parasites, produce healthier offspring, and, through reproduction, reduce the negative effects of small population size on the resident individuals.

Although we could translocate genetically dissimilar individuals, these may have different breeding, feeding, or predation avoidance behaviors that render them unsuitable for translocation to the new habitat. Additionally, these dissimilar individuals may be at greater risk of disease outbreak or parasite infestation because they do not possess local, genetic adaptations that help maintain the health of individuals already present on the reintroduction site. If we reintroduced genetically dissimilar individuals, the results could be catastrophic – many of the translocated birds may die or they may put resident birds at risk by diluting the resident population’s genetic adaptations to their local environment.

With this final example, the flexibility and power of genetic techniques should be evident. In this case, we can use genetic techniques to inform a future management decision directly by: (1) identifying a similar source population for a translocated species, (2) investigating the genetic “health” or genetic variability of both source and resident populations, and (3) provided it is our goal, allowing us to investigate the genetic effects of translocated individuals on the local population. Given use of these techniques in this way, we are able to make an informed, intelligent decision and monitor the outcome. In doing so, we maximize our benefits and minimize the risks associated with our actions.

Summary

In the preceding article, we have shown how genetics, genetic techniques, and genetic data can be used to aid the management of a rapidly declining population, identify unknown reproductive behavior, develop new hypotheses for further investigation, evaluate existing models of behavior, identify subspecies and hybrid zones, and guide the reintroduction of a species.

You may still be wondering how all of this affects landowners, hunters, natural resource managers, and/or biologists? As mentioned in many articles you have read, particularly Wildlife Trends, times are changing. The management of many species today is drastically different from management of the same species 50 years ago. Landscapes are becoming more fragmented and patches of managed land are smaller. We are beginning to be much more concerned with population structure, population size, individual dispersal, mating systems, inbreeding effects, and maintenance of genetic diversity. As a result, management increasingly focuses on actions taken to address these population features, and genetic techniques often allow us to investigate these features, better understand them, and make sound management decisions given our knowledge.

In certain cases, new management techniques (translocations, removals, sex-specific harvest schemes) are necessary to properly manage a particular patch or to bring native species back to a particular, well-managed area. In other cases, traditional management techniques are perfectly suitable. In all cases, we should be aware of both the short- and long-term effects of the techniques we use across the landscape. Genetic analysis is one tool among many that allows us to investigate these effects.

Genetic information is not a panacea, however. In some cases, the direct applicability of genetic data to a specific problem is evident. In others, the applicability of genetic data is currently unknown because: (1) we lack additional knowledge allowing us to fully understand the system in which we are working, or (2) we have not determined the best way to apply our knowledge to a management scenario.

It should also be remembered that these tools, like many others, are no substitute for sound biological knowledge, quality habitat, and continued habitat management. Provided quality habitat exists and when used in concert with other management techniques, genetic information can help to ensure the sound management, long-term persistence, and sustainability of our wildlife populations.

Additional Information

Here we have provided several examples illustrating the utility of genetics and genetic techniques to the field of wildlife management. This brief summary has only scratched the surface of the research being conducted in this area. Genetic techniques are currently being used with many other species as a part of numerous research projects. At the University of Georgia, several researchers are conducting genetic research among: Northern Bobwhite, bobcats, black bears, opossums, raccoons, Eastern Bluebirds, and loggerhead sea turtles.

If you would like to learn more about our research, please visit: http://gallus.forestry.uga.edu/lab. If you would like to learn more about some of the studies used as examples in this article, please visit the Molecular Genetics Core Laboratory of Randy DeYoung, (http://users.tamuk.edu/karwd00/Research.htm) or the website of Olin Rhodes’ for more on Emily Latch’s research (http://www.agriculture.purdue.edu/fnr/html/faculty/Rhodes/index.htm).